Customer Reviews

Link to our GooglePlus page Link to our yelp page

jeff cooper

February 21st, 2014

Professional service, professional results!

david farrior

February 21st, 2014

You went above and beyond what was expected. Your service, no, your help was great!!!

Mike Koval

February 21st, 2014

Services are always done in a timely manner. The staff are very friendly and have answered any questions that I might have.

L.M. Evanston, WY

February 21st, 2014

As always friendly and very helpfull service, Thanks

Roy Walworth

February 21st, 2014

I found the staff knowledgeable and competent. I appreciated that other problems were found and properly repaired.


March 8th, 2014

The old manager offered more services than just the getting tires and general maintance. I ended up taking my vehicle to Big O and they fixed my vehicle and they even got the part from the dealership

Carolin Maddux

February 21st, 2014

Friendly, courteous, quick, professional, did a great job!

Michael Stocks

February 21st, 2014

The new manager is very helpful and friendly. They have earned my business. I will buy tires from them as long as I live here. Mike

Jeff Murdock

February 22nd, 2014

The guys at the shop have been great to work with and have always been truthful. Thanks. Hard to find this quality in our country anymore.

john mortimer

February 22nd, 2014

Professional, on time, tried to make things personal. Shop was clean. employees were pleasant. All work was done on time and no problems with work.


March 23rd, 2014

Great service, thank you!!


March 31st, 2014

Great service:)

Tanya Bertagnolli

April 1st, 2014

I have told a lot people about you guys. You guys are awesome! Very professional !

Mike Koval

April 6th, 2014

Fast and friendly service.

Gordon Pulley

April 6th, 2014

My wife was the one that came in with a flat on here car. She said it only to 15 minutes and was happy as she was late for work!

Reba decker

April 14th, 2014

Great service....quick and friendly.


May 12th, 2014

When business is slow you don't jack up the price.... I am not sure the people who worked on my truck know what they are doing... I had to go inside to get my sticker to remind me to change oil again.


May 11th, 2014

Came in to use a coupon to have tires rotated. Unfortunately one of my tires had a big bubble on the inside sidewall. They told me about it, answered my questions, and made recommendations but weren't pushy instead allowed me to make my own decision.

dorinda tally

June 19th, 2014

it should not have taken your mechanics 4 times to get breaks right I went in there and had a set of brakes put on and they were like crap and they told me that it would take up to a thousand miles for them to start grabbing which I've never heard of that before so I went on a long trip came back they were still like crap so I paid to upgrade these brakes and when I upgraded they get a crappy job installing them I could not drive my car for a whole day and a half because it sounded like it was rubbing metal to metal took it back in and sure enough it was rubbing against my drama they had to resurface my drums which should have been done in the first place I feel that I should have never paid for the upgrade this is the worst service I've ever had on break in my life but I have to keep going back because that's where they were put on and that's where they were warranty but I would not reach anyone to place tires in Evanston Wyoming

tom condos

June 18th, 2014

Great price and exceptional service, right in and right out.

tom condos

September 18th, 2014

In and out with work done right and questions answered with a smile

connie berger

September 22nd, 2014

thanks great job

B.b. Evanston, WY

November 6th, 2014

The service department at the Evanston, Wyoming location are very incompetent in my view. They worked on my Jeep on Friday . When they finally finished flushing the cooling system, AFTER the mechanic broke the thermostat housing and taking ALL day to get the job done,it developed a leak in the cooling system over the weekend. I took it back the following Monday and THEY DIDN'T EVEN LOOK AT IT!!!!! I fixed the leak myself right after leaving YOUR location,about 1.5 miles. I had no choice,as the car was over-heating. As far as I am concerned all Plains will do for me from now on is ROTATE MY TIRES, until they wear out. Then I will go else where for ALL my needs!

Dennis Zager

November 18th, 2014

My only comment is the guy who talked to me about the fact I could'nt control all my power windows from the driver's side after the new battery was installed, didn't know how to fix it. It was in my owner's manual. It was very simple. He told me to have a Toyota dealer reprogram this.

Bryan C.

They have always been great to my family and I. The staff and techs at Plains Tires, are very friendly and knowledgeable about what they do and what they offer for their service. So far been the lowest price for services, tire, and rims. Plains Tires will always have my services.

Chance S.

Very efficient affordable and kind. Good experience.

Lonnie M.

As always friendly and very helpful service.

Becca B.

November 1st, 2016

I always choose plains tires to service my car. I can always count on the reliable service no matter which town I'm in. This Evanston location specifically was extremely helpful and willing to go above to fix my car

Michael S.

September 1st, 2016

Friendly, quick and understanding. Matt and Robert help us out on a day were we really needed it. Thanks guys.

Rose J.

August 1st, 2016

Plains Tire is my go to tire shop. They take great care of all my tire needs. Drop me off at work and work on my car. Great service!

Benjamin B.

July 1st, 2016

I was on a trip from Colorado to California with my family and had broken down on the interstate. We arrived on a Monday afternoon with our 2003 Saturn Vie on a tow truck. Matthew greeted us and calmed my nerves. He and Robert quickly diagnosed the problem (alternator), found the part in town, and did the work. The price was more than fair and we were back on the road in about an hour. I told Matt and Robert, you saved our day if not our trip. Great experience!

Michael E.

June 1st, 2016

Service is great! These guys always help me out quickly and professionally. Don't go anywhere else. They. do awesome job!

Lexi J.

June 1st, 2016

Robert (the mechanic) at plains tire was absolutely amazing. Gave me a very accurate estimate on my tires and did such an awesome job on my rotation and alignment! Props to Plains Tire!! Keep up the good work!

Donald S.

June 1st, 2016

Amazing and nice staff. Answered all questions and were fast with services.

Solomon S.

May 1st, 2016

I highly recommend you take your vehicle here! The mechanic Robert was very helpful and super friendly and did everything he could do to get me back on the road safe!! Thanks Plains Tire!!

Bruce G.

May 1st, 2016

My experience with Plains Tire was great. The service was fast and professional. The mechanic that worked on my car was very knowledgeable. He explained things in a way that was understandable, and walked me through what he had fixed. His name was Robert Gerber and I would definitely take my car back to him. Thank you and keep up the good work

Jason H.

May 1st, 2016

My son was on a road trip to Texas and I felt uneasy about his tires. I really wanted him to stop and have them balanced. I called ahead and talked to Jeff who totally stopped what he was doing and took care of my son. Jeff put me at ease and my son said that Jeff was awesome. I've never met Jeff and his store is two hours from my house but I felt like he was my neighbor and the service he provided to my son was so appreciated. Thank you Jeff.

Paul K.

May 1st, 2016

Very pleasant staff. Jeff, the manager, price matched with no issues! Hard to find a place so easy to deal with. Honesty and integrity makes this a 5 star in my book.

Kelly K.

May 1st, 2016

Jeff was awesome..very friendly and informative. He was great to work with!! Will definitely be back when we need more tires!!

Robert G.

May 1st, 2016

Jeff and the guys at Plains Tire are friendly and will do whatever it takes to make a customer happy!! Lowest prices in town!!

Winston W.

May 1st, 2016

Jeff and Robert are the most patient and most awesome guy you will ever meet. They make certain that every lugs bolts fluid was up to date on your car. I wouldn't go anywhere else to get my car worked on only Plains Tires in evanston wy. Thanks Jeff and Robert again.

Steve P.

April 1st, 2016

Plains Tires was extremely accommodating, professional, and got me right in. In addition, they communicated really well with me throughout the process, so that I knew what was going on and what to expect. I will continue to take my vehicles to Plains Tire in Evanston, Wyoming with any future vehicle repair and maintenance needs.

Chris C.

April 1st, 2016

They treated my family and I really well and even stayed late to mount new tires on our camper so we could make the trip to yellowstone.

Trinidad F.

April 1st, 2016

The guys at Plains Tire are so awesome! Always helpful honest and take good care of my vehicle and myself. Thank you Plains Tires. You’re like family!

Makayla W.

April 1st, 2016

Have had great experience. They have have not led me wrong on tires for either of our vehicles.

Joel E.

February 1st, 2016

Brought the tires several months ago had a great price. Brought the truck in for tire rotation. the tires were rotated in a very timely manner and fluid levels were checked. When filling the window washing fluid, a hose was found off the intake cooler. They filled the fluids and fixed the hose no charge. Thanks

Bryan C.

January 1st, 2016

They have always been great to my family and I. The staff and techs at Plains Tires, are very friendly and knowledgeable about what they do and what they offer for their service. So far been the lowest price for services, tire, and rims. Plains Tires will always have my services.

K. Reynolds

September 1st, 2016

They spin balanced my front tires - no wait - I test drove the car on I-80 and it was smooth! Great job, great service. It will really reduce the wear and tear on the tires. Exit 6 from I-80 if you're travelling.


April 1st, 2016

Great service at great prices. Service is always done quickly and correctly.